Roman Shade Roulette

All these questions! Is a little blind faith too much to ask?

– Sunday School Teacher

Time to revisit the DIY roman shade I made earlier this year (I’m also updating that post in detail to make sure the whole story is available there as well).

Executive Summary: As executed, it’s a d’oh!


After I finished the first blog-documented one, I became busy on other projects, and it took a while to get back to the other shade for that room. As time went on, I realized that I was stalling because I was not entirely happy with how the first shade operated. Basically, the model for the shade is a good one…if the shade is only one or two thin layers of fabric (the Little Green Notebook instructions used two thin layers). I also like the changes I made to the design (untying the cords rather than cutting, sewing rather than gluing important connections, and leaving an allowance to cover the mounting hardware). I believe the changes will make the unit more durable when implemented with a lightweight shade.

So I’m not trash-talking the overall project idea at all! What I AM saying is that, in my experience this project does not lend itself to a thicker shade including a black-out liner. When I first retracted the shade, I reported that it was bunchy because of the extra fabric.


That was easy to deal with by briefly fiddling with the folds so they fell better. This turned out to be a bit of a hassle, but no huge deal.

Not quite so bunchy.

But there was a fundamental issue I had not considered: the cords and mechanism are not really strong enough to deal with the lining’s extra weight. Miniblind slats are very lightweight, and so is a single-ply fabric blind. Every time I raise this shade, I think something is going to break. The whole thing just feels like it’s under too much physical stress. I’m loathe to raise the thing, and even less willing to de-bunch the folds because of my concern that I’m going to yank out one of the cords.

Jenny at LGN says that black-out lining could be included, so she has perhaps made a shade with a lining that worked well (I’ll check with her, but she’s a Real Blogger and Actual Designer, ergo very busy). If I hear back from Jenny and she has any tips, I will update this post — meanwhile, if anyone out there has ideas, please advise!

I have the base and the lift bar for the second shade, and I can probably reuse the base for the original unit with a lighter shade. I may do a lighter-weight shade and install them in Ben’s room, which is blind-deficient and has windows of the same size.

I have a replacement plan for the windows in our room — more on that soon. BECAUSE I KNOW YOU CAN’T WAIT!!! IT’S VERY EXCITING STUFF!!!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
This entry was posted in D'oh!, Decor, Windows & Doors and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Roman Shade Roulette

  1. mary says:

    I’ve slowly (?) read your whole blog. I can’t remember when I started, but after a push over this boring weekend I’m caught up! And hooked. I’ll be following along.
    You might be interested in this video:
    It’s *kind of* an ad, but not really. I followed the tutorial and made a sturdy roman shade out of materials I found elsewhere/around the house. The only adjustment I made was to not glue the dowels down, but to take the extra time to sew in a dowel rod-pocket instead. (If you watch, that will make sense). I’ve seen your couch slipcover, this is well within your wheelhouse.

    p.s.: the bedroom closet plans written-on-paper-and-taped-to-the-wall post was my favorite, too (re: your blogiversary post, written ? , but read about 2 hours ago)

    • Stacey says:

      Mary, thank you so much for the kind comment — I’m delighted you’re enjoying the blog! It’s fun to do, but it’s a huge bonus when people share things in the comments. And thank you for the link to the roman shade tutorial, I will check that out. I don’t have a permanent solution for 80% of the windows in this place.

      I now have the urge to tape signs to things for our next post. 🙂 Really looking forward to seeing you around here!

Leave a Reply to Stacey Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.