Finally, A Decision

Bart: Dad, you’re giving in to mob mentality.
Homer: No, I’m not–I’m hopping on the bandwagon. Come on, son, get with the winning team!

– The Simpsons

We ordered some countertops. Then I had to have a lie-down, because a major decision every six or seven years really takes it out of me.

We’d been through a stack of options, and created a short list of wood, zinc, and marble. We tried out a wood look, and decided it didn’t work. Zinc was also knocked out as aesthetically wrong for our tiny kitchen. Despite testing how marble would wear around messy cooks, my dream surface was eliminated as well. It turned out to be undoable with slab remnants, meaning a very high per-square-foot cost for buying a whole slab. We did consider marble mini-slabs, but we didn’t want the grout lines. We did more research, revised the list, and maybe did a bit more research.

Then Menards had a sale, and we ordered quartz.

Riverstone Quartz is Menards own brand of quartz surface. After our faux wood experiment, we settled on a light color and ordered “Cotton.” It’s almost entirely white with clear flecks.


White quartz is a nice, crisp look, and it will bounce light around the room.

During the recent kitchen sale, Menards offered this material starting at $30/square foot, plus charges for sink and faucet cut-outs. It’s pretty affordable at other times, too, but it’s worth waiting for a sale–they have them several times a year. You’ll need to provide double-checked measurements for each piece of counter, plus the position of the sink (measure for the midline of the sink you will use) and any cut-outs (faucet, drop-in range, extra sinks, etc.). You can buy a sink as part of the transaction, or provide the model and brand.

The Cotton pattern was one of the ones at the opening price; some other patterns were more expensive, but fortunately, we wanted the white. It’s an unbeatable deal, but installation is not included. Here are the other ups and downs for quartz counters: 


  • Quartz is described as a “bullet-proof” surface (which makes me want to try shooting it, but I’m a bit over-literal). It doesn’t stain, it doesn’t etch. Despite my marble trials, I have to admit that I was a tiny bit relieved that I wouldn’t have to test my true tolerance for etching.
  • Riverstone quartz is the same material as other quartz surfaces (93% quartz bound with acrylic), but fabricated for DIY installation, which is a huge money-saver.
  • The color we selected and the reflective finish will help light up our north-facing kitchen.


  • Quartz looks stone-like, but a uniform color like we chose won’t be mistaken for stone.
  • This is a serious DIY scenario. The material is heavy, and we’ll need to draft in some helpers.
  • Unlike some stone surfaces, it’s not advisable to place hot pots directly on quartz. We’re not in the habit of doing that anyway, but it’s a performance gap between quartz and granite.

We provided our measurements, and the factory will send us a vinyl template that we can roll out over our existing tops to check that everything is right before they proceed to fabrication. After that, the finished surfaces will be delivered to our local Menards in about three weeks. We’ll pull out the old counters and level everything before the heavy lifting begins.

I’m relieved to have the decision made so I can stop thinking about countertop materials. Now I can start thinking about countertop installation. Progress!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
This entry was posted in Decor, Kitchen and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Finally, A Decision

  1. Marshall Byler says:

    Any update on installation or living with it?

    • Stacey says:

      Yes — we love them! There’s an update post here, but basically, they clean up very easily, don’t seem to scratch, and look great. If you hit an edge hard and at the right angle, it might chip, but we haven’t had that happen (and we’re not easy on them). I’m really glad we went with the quartz! Thanks for asking.

  2. Phil says:

    Does this cotton color have any of the shiny flecs that catch the light?

    • Stacey says:

      Phil, yes, there are a few, but it doesn’t have an overall sparkly effect the way that some quartzes do.

  3. Rob Hartley says:

    Hi Stacey,

    What did you do for installation? DIY or did you have to hire someone?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.